The Syrian Civil war. Homes destroyed, family members murdered, all economic possibilities crushed. A person living in a village outside Alleppo sees Assad’s forces or ISIS (theocratic fascists) approaching….and they decide to leave their home for very good reason. They could be a supporter of the opposition or a Shi’ite Muslim. They had a good job, good prospects and a home life.
They leave their village and cross the border into Turkey. With no real border crossing or administration, they are now in Turkey illegally, but understandably relieved and SAFE from violence. So, without documentation, they declare to the Turkish administration or an aid agency that they are a refugee. It is the first safe place and its welcoming.
They try to wait for the end of the war. They get documents to show that they are a displaced person. They live in the camps run by various western aid agencies. They apply for the correct permits to live in Turkey. They see the war continuing and increasily bitter and destructive. They ultimately wish to go to their cousin in Spain or wherever, perhaps Britain and apply for visas and passports. They save up half the money by doing various jobs or savings and their cousin pays the other half. They go through the airport. All above board and correctly done. They finally arrived in Madrid and then reestablish some sort of life.
I have zero problem with this refugee.
But….what is happening is;
Civil War in Syria and a person leaves for Turkey and, as above, enters that country illegally.
Then they make the wrong decision.
They don’t want to live in the camps and they don’t want go back one day to a broken Syria. Fair enough. They understandable want a better life, but and here’s the very big BUT…..they don’t want to go through the proper processes, channels and checks. They are impatient or, and i can understand this, desperate for better. Then they cross, even though safe from Assad or ISIS, by a risky boat trip into Greece, walk up into Albania, cross into Bosnia, Croatia and either Hungary or Austria, then Germany and onwards to France. Finally, they arrive at The Jungle, Calais or a similar place.They try to illegally ride trucks, lorries or buses or enter the channel tunnel. Some even try swimming or sail across with the aid of Human traffickers. All of it ILLEGALLY done. The ceased being a refugee as soon as they step across the Turkish border. They become, in many peoples eyes, lawbreaking economic migrants. Men, women and the older looking children. This makes it harder for the refugees that Do go through the correct hurdles.
Sending them back to Turkey or the previous country they passed through may be Harsh policy*, but it’s what should be happening. This would done for practical purposes. A village on the “refugees trail” could be overrun briefly by hundreds of people…all needing shelter, food and water. To say that no criminal behaviour would occur is to be blinkered to the realities of the World. Also, criminal and/or nationalistic and xenophobic gangs may target them. They would cease to be SAFE once more!
I have sympathy and empathy for them, but if I tried crossing the channel, with no documents, by passed the authorities in France, crossed into Germany and got caught trying to get into Hungary or Poland..what would happen to me? ….I’d obviously get sent back to Britain. Might even get prosecuted for illegal entry. Criminal behaviour even.
Treat every one the same, they say? Hmmmmm.
It may be an awful strain, painstakingly slow and all most certainly an admistrational nightmare. Yes, i understand that! I do watch and read the news and I do think about how I would feel if I was in that situation. I stress this again…Going through the correct procedure is what should be happening. Money should be made available for this.
I’m definitely pro-refugees are welcome, but I add….”if they are legal and documented” They can take advantage of European free movement laws..only when they start out in a European country!
I hope you understand the nuance. They may want to come to Britain, but they should do it the Proper and Legal way. If you say that all undocumented, unassessed and unrecorded persons can enter Britain….you are probably RegressiveLeft and I’d have to argue against you. They may not want to live in France, Germany or Italy and want to come to Britain to seek a better life or connect with extended family members, but I really think they should have a better route planned out and follow the law.(I don’t understand why they don’t want to live in Germany…..all of the cities there look beautiful places to live in…and some of the countries these ‘refugees’ pass through have better rights and job opportunities than Britain!)
Footnote;
*I would have Kurds and Kurds from Syria fastracked to come to live in Britain. Kurds are not safe in Turkey and I would say that Turkey is a potential warzone for them. I’d extend the safe countries, for Kurds, to include Bulgaria and Greece. I’d still say that they have to follow the law and apply for documents.